Cookie policy

We use cookies for analytics, advertising and to improve our site. You agree to our use of cookies by hitting ‘Accept’ button, closing this message box or continuing to use our site. To find out more see our Privacy policy .

Accept
Ad
BOOK EXCERPT

Even the ‘unfinished’ Buddhist, Hindu and Jain temple caves in Ellora have stories to tell

An excerpt from ‘Ellora: Cross-fertilization of Style in Buddhist, Hindu and Jain Cave Temples’, edited by Deepanjana Klein and Arno Klein.

It is likely to come as a surprise to many to hear that the rock-cut site of Ellora, renowned for the grandeur of its richly sculpted monuments dedicated variously to the Buddhist, Hindu, and Jain faiths, carries a considerable degree of “unfinished” work. What exactly do we mean in this context by “finish” or the lack thereof? Finish implies firstly that none of the component parts of a monument are lacking or deficient. A finished monument is thus one which has all of its requisite parts – gateways, halls, porches, shrine, roofs, towers – and which depicts carved imagery appropriate to its dedication to one or other deity. Finish also implies that the various portions of a monument, and all its accompanying decorative and figural carvings, are crafted to a state of refinement so that nothing rough or inadequate remains. Recurring instances of lack of finish in both these senses are evident at Ellora, and they occur across the site and in caves dedicated to all three faiths. There is, for instance, a cave in which rock-cutters have not yet reached the stage of creating uniformly vertical walls or flat horizontal ceilings, but in which sculpted images have already been commenced. There are caves that are usable, but which reveal major areas of unfinished sculptural and architectural work. And there are caves that are almost complete but lack the element of refinement and finish in several details.

Why should “unfinished” work matter to us or be important in any way? Firstly, the substantial body of unfinished monuments at Ellora, and elsewhere in India, demands that we reassess pre-modern India’s attitude towards “finish.” The modern eye is so focused on finished work, especially in the case of the richly decorated monuments of India, that we tend to easily overlook the lack of finish. More often than not, such unfinished work may not be attributed to geological reasons such as bad strata of rock, or the sudden appearance of an underground spring of water, nor entirely to external factors such as natural disasters, wars, the death of a monarch, or the bankruptcy of a patron. It would appear rather that we need to come to terms with the fact that pre-modern India had a remarkably flexible and pragmatic approach towards the concept of finish.

I hope to demonstrate that once the shrine of a rock-cut sacred monument was ready for consecration and worship, patrons and worshipers appear to have found it unimportant, even irrelevant, to concern themselves with the detailed finish of the overall structure. As long as the sanctum was complete and subsidiary sacred images and/or sacred myths were clearly decipherable by devotees, it mattered little if figures within a panel remained somewhat incomplete, or if the panel’s framing pilasters were roughly cut. In Buddhist, Hindu, and Jain contexts, the patron who initiated the work, the rock-cutters who extracted the structure from a mountainside, the stone carvers who worked on the decorative details, as well as the devotees who worshiped therein, seem to have been able to ignore the fact that pillars remain incomplete, walls carry rough tool marks, and images remain partly obscured by the living rock. The very use of the word “unfinished” requires rethinking as it applies to pre-modern India, and this in turn necessitates a critical evaluation of what constituted an acceptable “sacred space.”

Before you scroll further…
Get the best of Scroll directly in your inbox for free.

Another reason to study unfinished work is that it is a statement of process, emphasising that stone carving is a subtractive process in which the artist/craftsperson is faced with a large mass of stone from which they have to remove matter to create their final product. Anything that is inadvertently or carelessly cut away cannot be put back or remodelled. Because of this, stone workers have always developed processes by which they gradually work upon and into the stone, thinking their way, one might say, towards the final surface. The process of stone carving has been likened to peeling an onion.1 Artists carve stone away in layers, and when work remains unfinished, one may trace the process involved in carving. At Ellora, there is visible evidence of the three sets of tools that they used. The preliminary tool is a pointed axe and/ or a pointed chisel with which 85% of the stone removed is cut away, leaving behind long, smooth lines as evidence of its work. All finer work was done with either a flat-headed or a rounded chisel, after which abrasives were used to create a smooth and even surface on the stone. Unfinished work also provides clear evidence of the top-down process of carving, in which the upper portions of a carved panel, an image, or a wall tend to be completed to a fine degree of finish, while the lower areas are often untouched. Presumably, rock-cutters developed this system because it minimized the use of scaffolding in the preliminary phase of work; in sculptural work, completing the head and face first would have enabled the artist to visualise clearly the proportionality of the figure.

It is useful to emphasise that what we call rock-cut architecture is, in fact, a sculptor’s technique in which the entire mountainside is the piece of rock to be sculpted by carving out portions to create interiors, and shaping other portions to form exteriors. There were none of the architect/builder’s problems of getting blocks cut to fit precisely together and to function safely in structural terms. Nor were there the many different tasks that need to be executed in construction, like quarrying, transport, lifting, and placing. But rock-cutting is by no means a simpler technique. How, for instance, do you measure from exterior to interior of a rock-cut monument, and maintain a row of columns in alignment, when the desired endpoint is deep within the yet unpenetrated rock of the hillside? In construction, it is possible to rectify errors while carrying on with the building, but in rock-cutting, stone that is carved away cannot be put back. Since there are no definitive examples in India where remedial work was attempted, it is clear that the architect and rock-carvers had developed an unknown technique of successfully working their way into a hillside with the barest minimum of mistakes.

Equally crucial in rock-cutting is the issue of spatial organisation, which involves fitting a group of workers into a confined space where there is no possibility of moving things around. In the preliminary stages, rock-cut architecture necessarily confines work to a space that is significantly smaller than the final spaces, and it requires careful planning to figure out the crucial issue of the organisation of the stone carvers. Another important issue is the amount of stone waste that is created by the process of excavating into a mountainside. A vast quantity of stone waste must be extracted to create the spacious interiors of halls of worship; in caves, where space is tight, stone waste needs to be cleared continually in order for the rock-cutters and the sculptors to proceed with their work.

In this brief exploration of unfinished work at Ellora, we will consider one monument dedicated to each of the three faiths represented at the site. We will follow the order of their arrangement along the low scarp of rock at the site where caves numbered 1–12 are dedicated to Buddhism, caves numbered 13–29 are Hindu in focus, and caves numbered 30–34 are of Jain affiliation.

Cave 2 is a structure intended purely as a hall of worship. It does not incorporate monastic residential cells, which are common in the context of Buddhist viharas (monastic residences). Its badly damaged veranda opens into a central courtyard-like space demarcated by twelve columns. Cut into the far wall is a sanctum whose wide and tall doorway is flanked by a monumental standing bodhisattva and a female attendant. Within the shrine is a finely finished haloed image of the Buddha of impressive dimensions, seated upon a lion throne. Against each side wall is a tall standing Buddha and an attendant bodhisattva, while its inner corners are occupied by a set of five kneeling devotees with hands in the anjali mudra (gesture of respect and adoration) and carved one above the other in vertical formation. Thus far, the cave is complete.

Advertisement
Ad

But Cave 2’s unusual plan includes two side wings or galleries that are raised slightly over four feet above the floor level of the rest of the cave, though without any steps to provide access to them. Each “gallery” features five deep bays cut into its side wall and separated from the next by deeply cut attached pillars. Each bay features a large image of the Buddha, seated on an elaborately decorated lion throne, with legs pendent and placed on the floor. Each Buddha is flanked by bodhisattvas, placed so as to face each other across the niche of the Buddha image, while a set of flying celestials complete the assemblage. All five Buddhas in the gallery to the right of the viewer entering the cave are complete, together with their attendant bodhisattvas and the bays in which they are seated. By contrast, the Buddhas in the left gallery, together with their attendants and the niches that contain them, display differing degrees of unfinishedness that leave us with a number of unanswered questions.

Ignoring the right gallery with its finished imagery, let us turn to the Buddhas in the left gallery, moving inwards from the cave’s exterior wall. The first and third of the five Buddhas are finished images, seated within a carefully carved and completed niche, and each haloed Buddha sits with knees apart and feet planted on a chandrashila (crescent-shaped platform) carved on the floor. A standing bodhisattva attendant, holding a flower in one hand, faces his counterpart across the width of each Buddha niche. The second Buddha in this left gallery is close to complete; however, his feet are not fully released from the stone below, his throne has not been finished, and his accompanying attendants await completion.

The final two Buddha images towards the inner end of the cave are in differing states of unfinished. The niche of Buddha number four has not yet been cut back to create a vertical rear wall, but curves in at the top and sides almost as if it were a natural cave. Since the sides of the niche have not been cut back, there is no indication as yet of the flanking bodhisattva figures. The central figure of the Buddha has been carved in three levels of finish. The most highly finished area is the head, followed by the shoulders, chest, and upper arms, while his feet are still embedded in the rock. His throne has not taken shape, so the Buddha sits on rough stone which extends across the cave-like niche. Buddha number five is in an even rougher state of unfinished. The only thing that is at all clear is the head that has been carved so as to be clearly recognisable. The rest of the figure, as well as the niche, remains an uneven mass of stone, cut down and back to varying heights and depths. Both images confirm that rock-cutting, as well as finer carving, commenced from the uppermost levels and moved down.

Crucial questions remain to be answered regarding Cave 2’s unfinished work. Did the stone carvers and their patrons consider the cave to be usable, since they could indeed offer worship to the Buddha within the cave’s sanctum? Was the cave’s unknown patron perhaps satisfied with the level of work executed on the cave, and hence able to ignore the unfinished left gallery? Did they perhaps run out of funding for their work? In terms of time taken, had the stone carvers already committed all their time and were expected to be elsewhere for another project?

An excerpt from ‘Unfinished Work at Ellora’ by Vidya Dehejia in Ellora: Cross-fertilization of Style in Buddhist, Hindu and Jain Cave Temples, edited by Deepanjana Klein and Arno Klein, Mapin Publishing.

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Get the app Get the app

We need your help

Your $120 a year helps us protect Indian democracy. Become a Scroll Member.

Already a subscriber? Sign In

Indian democracy needs you.

Act now

Your $120 a year helps us protect Indian democracy. Become a Scroll Member.

BOOK EXCERPT

Fiction: Three women from Kolkata are on a journey across the worlds of the living and the dead

An excerpt from ‘And I Am the Arrow’, by Pia Ghosh-Roy.

Men are bastards, Mishu-moni, was a pronouncement for which my grandmother switched to English. She’d pause for effect, take a measured sip of her whisky and tell me stories of bastardous men.

I was 13 or 14 at the time. Thima somewhere in her sixties, with a dead husband and a dead son behind her, and her body neatly divided into three sufferings – spondylosis on top, irritable bowel in the middle, arthritis below.

But her evening ritual did not suffer.

At half past six, when other grandmothers in other houses were lighting incense, ringing their little brass bells and sending up prayers to 33 crore gods, Thima attended to more important business. She unlocked her almirah, stroked her chiffons and organzas for the right sari to wear, before ringing her own little brass bell for Bani, our help, to bring in a glass of Scotch.

Thima. In front of the mirror. In a perfectly tailored sleeveless blouse, matching petticoat. Thima wrapping her sari in intricate folds and tucks, her fingers spread out like a dancer’s mudra, swishing this way and that, magically gathering cloth into neat concertina pleats like the paper fans I made on breezeless summer days. ...

BOOK EXCERPT

For children: A peepul tree in Lucknow’s Sikandar Bagh recounts the 1857 revolt

An excerpt from ‘People, Places, Things: The Story Of 1857’, by Nandini Nayar.

The peepul of Sikandar Bagh! That is how the people of Lucknow know me. I am the tree that is the heart of the bagh, the centre around which it grew. My branches spread wide and many birds perch there. I cast a thick shade that travellers enjoy in the summer. And in winter, my Sikander Bagh comes alive with the sounds of laughter and of music. Crowds gather then to enjoy a musical evening, while the stars slowly flicker to life in the sky above.

But that was in the past, when the Nawab lived here. Things changed last year and it happened so gradually that I barely noticed. Fewer and fewer people walked in to relax in Sikander Bagh. I started hearing the hurried shuffle of feet, angry whispers, and sometimes shouts. As the sun grew hotter, the anger grew, too. Then one day, it burst out. Lucknow was shaken by shouts, yells, and screams. It has begun, I thought. And yet, I did not know what exactly had started or how it would change my city.

As the sun grew harsher, the booms and shouts grew louder and more frequent. Screams became a part of my world. They scared the birds into flapping in terror, sending clouds of them rising into the air, squawking and crying. There were days when the earth shuddered. And I was afraid....

BOOK EXCERPT

How public canteens in India are creating jobs, supporting women, and fostering democratic spaces

An excerpt from ‘Freebies or Rights: Understanding Social Policy in India,’ by Reetika Khera.

Canteens are under-researched not only in India, but elsewhere too. Therefore, in November-December 2023, we conducted The Canteen Survey 2023 in three states – Karnataka, Rajasthan and Tamil Nadu. The purpose was to understand the role of canteens and how well or poorly they are implemented.

One persistent problem with canteen schemes is that they have fallen prey to petty politicking at the state level. This can take different forms: in Andhra Pradesh, Anna Canteens were closed en masse. In Karnataka, the Congress government introduced Indira Canteens in 2017. When the BJP government came to power in the state, there were budget cuts, layoffs and in some canteens, opening hours were curtailed. Tamil Nadu’s Amma Canteens, which started in 2013, benefited from the fact that the party that introduced the scheme (the AIADMK) remained in power until 2021. When the government changed, there was a widespread perception that Amma Canteens were being neglected.

Rajasthan’s Indira Rasois were just three years old, when elections became due (in November 2023). This created the possibility that a change in government could lead to the neglect or closure of canteens. The Canteen Survey 2023 was conducted before this could happen in Rajasthan, and to study the implementation of older canteen schemes in Karnataka and Tamil Nadu. ...

BOOK EXCERPT

Fiction: Joachim is in a rut in Mangalore, so he sets off for Bahrain. But life there is even harder

An excerpt from ‘You Envy the Coutinhos’, by Michelle D’costa.

Joachim remembers Crystal from time to time. He recently heard she eloped with a gangster, and no one has heard from her ever since. He is happy his wife Emilda is far more beautiful than her and that he gets to see her every day at work and at home. It had been raining the day she landed in Bahrain wearing a yellow salwar kameez. He had been tempted to lift her and dance in the rain. He will never forget that day; the way the rain had upset her. She had been quiet for a long time, and he had tried different ways to make her speak or respond in some way. Finally, she had admitted to being upset because he had lied about the rain. “What else have you been lying about?” she’d asked. He had laughed, making her even more furious.

But when they reached home, she had kissed his cheek on finding out he had gotten rid of his female flatmate for her. He had frowned, disappointed at her aim and pointed at his lips. She had then blushed and helped him unbutton his shirt, aiming for his nipple instead. A bold move which aroused and irked him at the same time. “Where did you learn to do that?” he’d said irritably, his thick eyebrows furrowed together....

BOOK EXCERPT

A new book suggests dressing consciously can be a practice in mindful living

An excerpt from ‘Everyday Etiquette: The Art of Mindful Living’, by Manik Kaur.

Clothes are not just fabric. They are the first sentence of every story you tell about yourself, written before you have opened your mouth, before anyone has heard your name or understood your intentions. Whether you are conscious of it or not, every morning when you open your wardrobe you are making a series of quiet decisions about how you wish to be received by the world that day.

The question is not whether your clothes communicate. They always do.

The question is whether what they are saying is what you mean.

My grandmother never once dressed for an audience.

She dressed for herself – with the same care and intention whether she was receiving visitors or spending a solitary afternoon in the garden. Her standards did not fluctuate based on who was watching. They were simply her standards, maintained because they reflected who she was rather than what she wanted others to think of her.

This is the foundation of dressing with intention, and it is almost entirely the opposite of how most people approach getting dressed today. ...

BOOK EXCERPT

How illnesses like smallpox in colonial India exposed Britain’s myths of control and invincibility

An excerpt from ‘In Sickness and In Death: How Faith, Medicine and Race Shaped British India’, by Ipshita Nath.

As we know, the fear of contagion predominated most British reports of infectious diseases in India. The tropical climate of the subcontinent was blamed once again and the dangers of the “miasmatic emanation” were discussed frequently. As sanitary improvements were introduced under the colonial regime, reflecting the hygiene consciousness of the mid-19th century in Europe, the dread of the miasmatic towns of India intensified, leading to the increased focus on social class as a determinant of smallpox. In fact, poverty was discussed as a key element; it became an important factor in the epidemics. Consequently, the filthy habits of people, yet again, acquired prominence in the diagnosis and treatment of the disease.

Unfortunately for the British, while cholera and later plague were assigned to filthiness, smallpox did not particularly favour the black towns or the overcrowded chawls in the big cities. Once it struck, it quickly spread through the towns and villages alike, apparently without distinguishing between race and class. Still, administrative reports of the 19th century denounced the ignorant people of India for not being hygienic, and for dwelling in insanitary conditions, especially for living in “credulity and childish ignorance”. Given that miasmas continued to be blamed for contagion well into the 19th century, the stench from the bodies of smallpox victims – during their removal, as well as during their carriage to, and exposure on the banks of the river – was thought to “taint” the air with its malodours that were believed to carry the disease, and pass it to those who came in contact with it. This came to be understood as a cause of its diffusion....

Book review

‘Chakmak’: A poetry collection about tribal life is essential for the re-education of the urban mind

Poet Ramesh Karthik Nayak was awarded the 2024 Sahitya Akademi Yuva Puraskar for these poems.

Some time ago, I spent a week staying among and interacting with the staff and the students at three remote tribal schools of Dahanu Taluka in Maharashtra’s Palghar District. I stayed long enough to catch bursts of ebullience on the school playground day after day. That ebullience is the very force of nature running through their veins – the nature that they don’t see themselves as being distinct from.

Ramesh Karthik Nayak’s poetry collection Chakmak is replete with bursts of the very same ebullience throughout this book. It is best manifested in the way Nayak constructs his imagery. The abstract nouns or the qualitative adjectives that account for the lock, stock, and barrel of much of the imagery in mainstream poetry are not his weapons. Instead, it is the action verbs that convey the images in his poems. Consider the way Nayak captures nightlife in a forest:

Bats and owls
ransack the night.

— from ‘Night’

He strips the image to the bare minimum and then lets the verb carry it. All the vividity and the vivacity of that image come from that one word: ransack. Even when an image is loaded with sensory words, it is his verbs that carry the image:...

Book review

‘London Falling’: A captivating investigation into a 19-year-old’s double life and death in London

Ostensibly about the death of a teenager, Zac Brettler, the book is a matryoshka doll of stories with charming rogues, liars, criminals and the nefarious types.

In September, 2015, Patrick Radden Keefe wrote about Ken Dornstein, whose older brother David had perished in Pan Am Flight 103 which had exploded mid-air, six miles above the earth. The debris fell over Lockerbie, Scotland. Over many decades, Ken kept trying to solve the murder mystery of his brother’s death. Who was responsible?

If a writer’s career is a sum of its parts, then all of Patrick Radden Keefe’s career has led to London Falling, his most recent non-fiction book. Ostensibly about the death of a teenager, Zac Brettler, in 2019, the book is a matryoshka doll of stories with charming rogues, liars, criminals and various nefarious types. At the heart of the tale, the centre of it is the grief and bewilderment of Zac Brettler’s parents, both children of Holocaust survivors, thoroughly decent folks who realise that their teenage son, while alive, was a fabulist of the highest order. Zac went around lying to everyone about his family and wealth. Using the name Zac Ismailov, he claimed to have been the son of a Russian oligarch....

Sunday book pick

Sunday book pick: The specific curse of dating men in ‘Nearly All the Men in Lagos Are Mad’

Published in 2021, this is Nigerian writer Damilare Kuku’s debut book.

Nigeria’s biggest city, Lagos, resembles a proper madhouse in Damilare Kuku’s 2021 debut book, the short story collection Nearly All the Men in Lagos Are Mad. It is hot and populous, and everyone’s hustling for more money or better sex. The men take shortcuts for both and women trip over themselves trying to make sense of this collective madness. Time and again they realise there is no substitute for extreme caution.

A heady romancescape

The 12 stories in the collection describe the experiences of cisgender women in various stages of heterosexual relationships. Women of all age groups and socio-economic classes suffer the madness of their men – but few take it lying down, finding ways to make the most out of their compromised circumstances. The title is catchy and relatable, and women in every city in the world will nod in approval. The men are a diverse set too, from cheating pastors to mama’s boys, from gay men to “alpha” Whites, men who endlessly pursue and those who are emotionally unavailable. Lagos’s heady romancescape often sweeps up unsuspecting women in its unique madness....

MEET THE WRITER

‘Writing to dazzle can be a fatal mistake of the preoccupation with writerly craft’: Saikat Majumdar

An interview with the author of ‘Open Intelligence: Education Between Art and Artificial’.

Having read several of Saikat Majumdar’s novels and a couple of his non-fiction books, I consider him one of those rare contemporary writers who move seamlessly across fiction, nonfiction, and academia – embodying the spirit of a true literary polymath. What I find particularly compelling about his writing is the way it inhabits both intimacy and ideas with equal ease. His novels delve into love, desire, friendship, memory, cities, and the shifting textures of modern life with emotional acuity, while his nonfiction carries the same depth through sharp insight and elegant prose. Across genres, his writing has consistently challenged and moved me, often leaving me with unexpected reflections long after I’ve finished reading.

In a conversation with Scroll, Majumdar talked about his latest book Open Intelligence: Education Between Art and Artificial, the value of narrative intelligence, why we urgently need to re-evaluate our intellect, and more. Excerpts from the interview:

Let me begin by saying that I’ve long admired your fiction – you are among my favourite contemporary Indian writers. So, I’m especially curious to know what prompted Saikat Majumdar, the novelist, to write Open Intelligence: Education Between Art and Artificial?
Fair question. Writing through the years, the technical difference between genres feels less important than certain overarching preoccupations that are now finally taking shape for me. One such concern is a certain ability of language to shock and surprise, to evoke a sensory, atmospheric reality. Likewise, the fundamental question of how we take shape as the characters we eventually become – our making and education, but one that is not limited to institutions: school, college, university, though obviously they are significant too. The Bildungsroman, also called the novel of education or the coming-of-age story, has been important to me, particularly through the question of sexuality and the self-making of the artist or the intellectual, as you might sense in novels like The Firebird, The Scent of God, or

Ad